Key takeaways
- AI assistants name businesses they can find and confirm in many places: your Google Business Profile, reviews, website, listings and mentions on other sites.
- Each assistant reads different sources. ChatGPT’s search uses providers such as Bing plus OpenAI’s own crawler; Gemini and AI Overviews use Google’s index and Maps data.
- Plain, specific answers on your own website are what AI tools quote.
- Check where you stand first, then re-check every month.
- Nobody can guarantee an AI recommendation. You can make your business the easiest one to recommend.
How AI assistants choose which businesses to name
When someone asks ChatGPT for the best Italian restaurant in Red Bank, the assistant searches the web, reads the listings and pages it finds, and writes a short answer from the sources it trusts most. Across the tests we run for clients, the businesses that get named tend to have four things in common:
- The same details everywhere. Name, address, phone and services match on Google, Bing, Apple, Yelp, Facebook and their own site.
- Plenty of recent, specific reviews. Reviews that say what was good and where.
- A website that says it plainly. What they do, where, for whom, with real answers to real questions.
- Mentions on other sites. Local news, “best of” lists, the chamber of commerce, industry directories.
Each assistant draws on different sources. ChatGPT’s search uses third-party search providers, Bing among them, plus OpenAI’s own crawler. Gemini and Google’s AI Overviews use Google’s index and Google Maps data. Perplexity runs its own searches and cites the pages it uses. That is why a business can come up first on one assistant and not at all on another.
Step 1: Find out where you stand
Ask the assistants the questions your customers ask, such as “best dentist in Holmdel” or “who does kitchen remodels near Long Branch”. Ask while logged out, and ask more than once, because answers change from one try to the next. Write down who gets named and which websites get cited.
Our free AI check does this for ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity in about a minute.
Step 2: Make your Google Business Profile complete
Pick the primary category that matches what most customers search for, list every service, keep hours right (holidays too), add real photos and post every week. Then claim Bing Places for Business and Apple Business Connect with the same details: Bing’s data feeds Microsoft Copilot and is one of the sources behind ChatGPT’s search, and Apple’s feeds Siri and Apple Maps.
Our full checklist is in How to rank in the Google Maps top 3.
Step 3: Earn reviews that say what you do and where
Ask every happy customer, right after the visit or the job, with a direct link or QR code. A review that says “best brick-oven pizza in Matawan” tells an AI exactly what you are good at and where. Reply to every review, good or bad.
Never buy reviews or write your own. Fake reviews break Google’s rules and the FTC’s, and they can get a profile suspended.
Step 4: Put clear answers on your website
- A page for each service and each town you serve, with real details, not the same text with the town name swapped.
- Open each page with a two- or three-sentence answer to the question it targets, then go into detail.
- An FAQ with the questions customers actually ask on the phone.
- Facts an AI can quote: address, phone, hours, the year you opened, the areas you serve.
- Structured data (LocalBusiness and FAQ schema) so machines read those facts without guessing.
- Text in the page, not in images, readable without logging in, and fast on a phone.
Also check that your robots.txt does not block the crawlers AI tools use, such as OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot, Googlebot and Bingbot.
Step 5: Keep your name, address and phone identical everywhere
Google, Bing, Apple, Yelp, Facebook, Instagram and your industry’s directories should all show the same name, address, phone and hours. When sources disagree, AI tools are less sure the business is still open, or which location is right, and are less likely to recommend it.
Step 6: Get mentioned on other sites
Local news stories, the chamber of commerce, sponsorships, “best of” lists, partner and supplier websites and industry associations all count. AI answers often cite exactly these pages. Local creator content helps too: our creator platform sends local creators to visit and post about our clients.
Step 7: Measure it every month
Ask the same questions every month and track how often each assistant names you. Visits from AI tools often arrive as phone calls or direct visits, so use call tracking to see what they bring in.
What this looks like for our clients
In AI visibility tests in October 2026, Patricia’s of Holmdel came up #1 among local restaurants on ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, named in 76%, 71% and 76% of answers. Over Easy Kitchen was #1 on all three as well (42%, 68% and 42%). We repeat these tests to track each client over time.
What doesn’t work
- Hundreds of near-identical town pages.
- Pages stuffed with keywords or written by AI with nothing new to say.
- Fake or paid reviews.
- Anyone selling a guaranteed spot in ChatGPT.
