732-900-3621 Get my growth plan
Menu
Get my free growth plan Call 732-900-3621

Guide · Hiring an agency

How to choose a marketing agency in Monmouth County.

Plenty of business owners hire an agency once, get burned, and swear off agencies for good. This is the checklist we would use if we were hiring one ourselves. We are an agency in Tinton Falls, so read it knowing that.

By the Smart Marketing team · Tinton Falls, NJ · Updated Nov 2026

Key takeaways

  • Ask for results with a date range and a client you can look up.
  • Find out who actually does the work.
  • Make sure you own your website, domain, ad accounts and Google Business Profile.
  • Insist on call tracking and a monthly report in plain numbers.
  • Walk away from anyone who guarantees rankings or AI recommendations.

Full-service agency or specialists?

A full-service agency runs your content, ads, website and SEO with one team and one plan. Specialists go deep on a single channel. Full-service suits a busy owner who wants one point of contact; specialists suit a company with its own marketing manager to coordinate them. Either way, someone has to own the whole picture.

Eight things to check

  1. Results with dates. Real numbers come with a date range and a client name you can look up. “We tripled a client’s leads” with no dates is a story, not proof.
  2. Who does the work. Ask whether photos, video, ads and websites are done by their own staff or passed to subcontractors. Either can work, but you should know.
  3. Local presence. Can they shoot at your business this week? A local crew means fresh photos and video instead of stock.
  4. Tracking. Every call, form and order should be tied to the channel that produced it. Without call tracking, nobody can tell you what is working.
  5. Reporting. A monthly report you can read in five minutes, compared with the month before, with what they will change next.
  6. Ownership. You should own your domain, website, Google Business Profile, ad accounts and social accounts. The agency should work inside them with access you grant.
  7. Industry experience. Ask for two clients in your industry and what they did differently for them.
  8. A clear first 90 days. They should be able to tell you what happens in week one, month one and month three.

Ten questions to ask before you sign

  1. Can I talk to two current clients in my industry?
  2. Who will be my day-to-day contact, and how fast do they reply?
  3. Who shoots, edits and writes, and are they on your staff?
  4. Will I own my website, domain, ad accounts and Google profile?
  5. How do you track calls and leads back to each channel?
  6. What will my monthly report show?
  7. What happens in the first 90 days?
  8. How do you decide where my ad budget goes?
  9. What do you need from me each month?
  10. If it isn’t working, how do I leave, and what do I keep?

Red flags

  • Guaranteed #1 rankings or guaranteed AI recommendations.
  • Results with no dates, no names, or screenshots you can’t check.
  • Ad accounts or websites set up in the agency’s name instead of yours.
  • No call tracking, or reports full of impressions and likes but no calls or sales.
  • A different contact every month.
  • Pressure to sign today.

Where Smart Marketing fits, and where we don’t

We are a full-service agency in Tinton Falls with our own photo and video crew. We are built for local businesses that want one team running content, ads, website, SEO and AI search together: restaurants, spas and med spas, dental and medical practices, contractors and home services, gyms and venues across Monmouth, Ocean and Middlesex Counties and Staten Island.

We are probably not the right fit if you only need a one-off logo or a single print job, or if your main need is national PR or TV and radio buying.

Judge us the same way: our case studies show every result with its date range, and our reviews page has client videos and our Google ratings.

Smart Marketing at a glance

Founded2015, by Emilio and Randy Duran
Studio923 Green Grove Rd, Suite 202, Tinton Falls, NJ 07712
Office20 Clark Pl, Middletown, NJ 07748
Team17+ specialists (Nov 2026)
Clients80+ active businesses (2026)
PartnersGoogle Partner · Meta Business Partner
Google rating5.0 Tinton Falls (9 reviews) · 4.8 Middletown (38 reviews)
Phone732-900-3621 (Mon–Fri, 9 AM–5 PM)

Good questions.

What does a marketing agency do for a small business?

It plans and runs the work that brings in customers: social media, photo and video, ads, the website, SEO, the Google profile and the reporting that shows what is working.

Should I hire a local marketing agency or a national one?

If you serve one area, a local agency can shoot at your business, meet you in person and knows the towns and seasons you sell in. A national firm can suit a brand spread across many states.

How long before marketing shows results?

Ads can bring calls soon after they launch. SEO and AI search build over months. A good agency tells you which to expect when, and shows you the numbers every month.

How much does a marketing agency cost?

It depends on the services, the number of locations and how much content you need. We build every plan around the business, so we start with a free growth plan and a recommendation before talking about a budget.

What is the difference between an agency and a freelancer?

A freelancer is usually one person with one skill. An agency brings a team, so content, ads, website and reporting are covered, and the work doesn’t stop when one person is out.

Free growth plan

Let's make your phone ring.

Start with your name and number. A few quick questions after that, and a strategist calls you with a plan built for your goals. No cost, no pressure.

Ready for more customers?Let’s talk about your business

Prefer to talk? Call 732-900-3621

Smart Marketing · Free growth plan

Let’s talk about your business

A plan for your business, not a sales pitch. About a minute.

What brings you here?